pipette
ENEnglish

The sound of persuasion: Using generative AI to identify gender gaps in political influence

Ethan Craig Busby, Lisa P. Argyle, Parker Davis, Joshua R. Gubler, Bryce Hepner, Christopher F. Karpowitz, Alex Lyman, Justin Olcott, Jessica Preece, David Wingate

Revista con revisión por paresFácil de leer

En palabras de los autores

Women often experience a deficit in persuasive influence, particularly in contexts like politics, where expectations about women’s behavior may conflict with gendered expectations about the domain and role. In spite of this widespread pattern, the mechanisms behind the gender gap in persuasion are difficult to isolate and test in dynamic political conversations. Women may be less persuasive simply because role-based expectations prompt others to afford women less authority when speaking about politics generally or about some political topics. Alternatively, women may be less persuasive because they tend to use linguistic patterns or rhetorical strategies that are less effective. Using an original AI-based approach, we put 4,300 human subjects into realistic, real-time phone conversations with an AI agent. These agents were randomly assigned either a masculine or feminine gendered conversation topic and a male- or female-sounding voice, allowing us to manipulate topic and perceptions of speakers’ gender while holding constant other elements of rhetorical content and strategy. After validating the experimental treatments, we find no direct effects of perceived gender of the AI agent, as cued by voice. However, gender affects other important aspects of the persuasive interaction. Research subjects were more likely to be persuaded about the masculine topic (defense spending) than the feminine topic (aid to the poor). Additionally, women research subjects were, on average, more persuaded than men. To the extent that men and women emphasize different topics in political conversations and have different discussion partners, these dynamics are likely to shape women’s political persuasive influence.

Resultado principalEl resumen no menciona limitaciones.

En palabras simples Resumen con IA

Los investigadores usaron inteligencia artificial para crear conversaciones telefónicas realistas con 4,300 personas. Los agentes de inteligencia artificial tenían voces que sonaban masculinas o femeninas y discutían temas masculinos o femeninos. La voz por sí sola no cambió directamente qué tan persuasivo era el agente de inteligencia artificial. Las personas se sintieron más persuadidas por el tema masculino, gasto en defensa, que por el tema femenino, ayuda a los pobres. Las mujeres participantes fueron, en promedio, más persuadidas que los hombres.

Escrito por Kimi K2.5 usando solo el abstract de arriba. Jev verificó que cada oración esté respaldada por las oraciones del abstract que cita y eliminó las que no. Pasá el cursor por una oración para ver de dónde sale.

Apareció: jueves, 19 de noviembre. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Revista con revisión por pares.

DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2615776123