Benchmarking honorific academic recognitions against citation metrics
En palabras de los autores
We examined how diverse metrics track individuals receiving major honorific recognitions and whether higher, more prestigious recognitions are associated with higher coverage among a database of top-cited scientists. We assessed with Scopus data the newly inducted (in 2026) 2,038 members of 14 major academies and honorific societies, endowed professors at Stanford University (n=773) and Michigan State University (MSU) endowed professors (n=129) and distinguished professors (n=112), and Nobel (n=166) and Turing (n=25) laureates awarded in 2010-2026 (n=191) for total publications, total citations, h-index, coauthorship-adjusted hm-index, citations to single-, single/first-, and single-/first-/last-authored (SFL) publications, and a composite citation indicator (c-score). For those with [≥]5 full papers and [≥]20 published items indexed in Scopus, metrics were mapped as percentile values among authors sharing the same primary scientific subfield and [≥]5 full papers. Citations to SFL publications had most frequently the best median percentile values and c-score had the best median of median percentile values (0.81%). Subfield-adjusted median percentile values were 0.04-0.23% for Turing/Nobel, 0.23-3.01% for academies and honorific societies, 2.74% for MSU endowed professors, 1.29% for MSU distinguished professors, 0.94% for Stanford endowed professors for citations to SFL publications; and 0.04-0.26%, 0.36-3.85%, 3.21%, 1.55%, 1.03%, respectively, for c-score. The percentages of honorees included in the Stanford/Elsevier listing of top-cited scientists (top-2% of c-score in their scientific subfield or top-100,000 in c-score across all science) followed the perceived prestige gradient: 99% for Turing/Nobel laureates, 84-92% for the national US academies and the UK Royal Society as well as AAP and ACM, 51-76% for other academies/societies, 78% for Stanford endowed professorships, 72% for distinguished MSU professorships, 52% for MSU endowed professorships. Several honored scientists had at least one retraction (highest for medicine (17.5%) and chemistry (11.4%) Nobel laureates), and few had very high proportion of papers in Scopus-discontinued titles, while high self-citations were rarely encountered. Metrics may influence honors and vice versa. The current evidence suggests strong tracking of the median values, especially for citations to SFL publications and c-score, against major recognitions; and a gradient of coverage in a list of top-cited scientists congruent with the perceived relative prestige of these recognitions.
Apareció: miércoles, 18 de noviembre. bioRxiv. Preprint, todavía sin revisión por pares.