Consensus Formation History Shapes Collective Updating
En palabras de los autores
Consensus is rarely a one-off achievement. In a changing world, groups must repeatedly update judgments they have already agreed upon, making consensus updating a common feature of real-world collective decisions. However, previous research on collective decision-making has focused mainly on how groups reach a single consensus, leaving the updating of established consensus largely unexamined. This raises two unanswered questions: does consensus updating involve biases analogous to sunk cost, and are such biases related to the cost of the previous consensus? Building a Fake Consensus paradigm, we manipulated consensus-formation cost and examined how dyads updated a subjectively established consensus after new information arrived. An independent individual experiment provided information-matched updating baselines, allowing us to determine whether dyads updated less or more than individuals responding to the same evidence. Contrary to sunk-cost predictions, low-cost consensus led dyads to update less than the individual baseline, whereas medium- and high-cost consensus led them to update more. The pathway through perceived consensus sharedness was significant, and the association between sharedness and updating was stronger at higher left temporoparietal junction inter-brain synchrony. These findings indicate that the history of consensus formation shapes subsequent updating by altering the psychological meaning of shared endorsement, while interpersonal alignment determines how this shared experience translates into coordinated behavior. To our knowledge, this is the first experimentally controlled study of consensus updating in teams to isolate formation history from actual disagreement, providing a new paradigm for studying how collective judgments change after agreement.
En palabras simples Resumen con IA
Los grupos a menudo necesitan revisar acuerdos que ya habían hecho cuando aparece nueva información. Los investigadores crearon un método de Falso Consenso para probar cómo las parejas actualizaban su acuerdo. Las parejas con consenso barato actualizaron menos que los individuos, pero las parejas con consenso costoso actualizaron más. Qué tan fuertemente las parejas sentían que compartían la misma opinión afectaba su actualización. Este es el primer estudio controlado que separa la historia del consenso del desacuerdo real.
Escrito por Kimi K2.5 usando solo el abstract de arriba. Jev verificó que cada oración esté respaldada por las oraciones del abstract que cita y eliminó las que no. Pasá el cursor por una oración para ver de dónde sale.
Apareció: miércoles, 30 de septiembre. bioRxiv. Preprint, todavía sin revisión por pares.