pipette
ENEnglish

Graph-regularized synthetic control for spatial panels with post-only treated locations

Hajime Seya, Ryosei Moriwaki, Daisuke Murakami

Preprint

En palabras de los autores

Spatial policy panels can contain treated locations that are observed only after an intervention and therefore have no pre-treatment outcome history. Without a pre-treatment trajectory to match, choosing donor weights for such post-only locations requires an additional source of information. We propose Graph-SCM, which estimates donor weights jointly across treated locations and encourages geographically neighboring locations to use similar donor combinations. GeoEco-SCM keeps the same geographic graph but adjusts the strength of its existing edges using pre-treatment economic similarity. Both methods handle complete, partial, and absent histories within one convex weight-estimation problem. Monte Carlo experiments compare them with covariate-balanced synthetic controls, equally weighted donor averages, ordinary synthetic control where estimable, and nonseparable spatio-temporal imputation and direct prediction. No method dominates. Graph-based borrowing improves on covariate balancing in several settings, but a selective-coverage design favors covariate balancing. Economic adjustment helps when geography alone misses relevant donor relationships. The results support graph regularization as a way to extend synthetic-control coverage when connected locations share similar donor representations, with its usefulness depending on the structure of the available information.

Resultado principalLimitación que admiten los autores

Apareció: martes, 10 de noviembre. arXiv. Preprint, todavía sin revisión por pares.

Comentario de los autores: Supplementary material included. R replication code (version 0.0.0): https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24056020