Telling coordination from coincidence: a no-interaction twin for collective systems
En palabras de los autores
Measures of emergence based on information theory or causal closure ask whether a group variable has a predictable law of its own, but not whether that law was produced by the members' interactions: the centre of mass of non-interacting random walkers passes the standard criterion . We introduce the interaction share S, the fraction of the forecast error of a system's no-interaction twin (the same members with every interaction removed) that the real group law eliminates, and a projected estimator with expectation zero without interaction. For Gaussian forecasts, is the expected Kullback-Leibler divergence of the real group law from the twin's. S is exactly zero for the centre of mass of linearly coupled walkers, and a machine-checked proof extends this to any pairwise force obeying Newton's third law. Across magnets, oscillators and flocking models it rises from 0 to about 1 where collective order appears. With time-shifted virtual groups and positive controls, it separates real fish schools (0.54-0.91, 17 recordings, two species) from groups that never interacted (-0.10 to 0.07), and it falls to zero when zebrafish are placed in the dark. In 221 mouse brain areas and in US stock markets the shares are small (about 1-3%) and were confirmed in pre-registered tests on unseen data. For linear forecasts the share is a memory gap, computable from two autocorrelation curves without fitting a twin; it matches measured shares (Spearman 0.97) and predicted fresh markets within 0.004. All code, data pipelines and hashed pre-registrations are public.
En palabras simples Resumen con IA
Las medidas actuales de emergencia pueden confundir la coincidencia con la verdadera coordinación. Los autores crearon una nueva medida llamada proporción de interacción S. S compara un grupo real con una versión 'gemela' donde se eliminan todas las interacciones entre los miembros. Las escuelas reales de peces obtuvieron 0.54-0.91, mientras que los grupos que nunca interactuaron obtuvieron -0.10 a 0.07.
Escrito por Kimi K2.5 usando solo el abstract de arriba. Jev verificó que cada oración esté respaldada por las oraciones del abstract que cita y eliminó las que no. Pasá el cursor por una oración para ver de dónde sale. Se eliminó 1 oración por no estar respaldada por el abstract.
Apareció: martes, 10 de noviembre. arXiv. Preprint, todavía sin revisión por pares.
Comentario de los autores: 30 pages, 8 figures. Code, data pipelines and pre-registrations: https://github.com/icyou520/Telling-Coordination-from-Coincidence (archived at doi:10.5281/zenodo.23934342)