pipette
ENEnglish

Learning Lotteries with Minimal Stakeholder Violations from Membership Queries

Nicholas Teh, Paul W. Goldberg

Preprint

En palabras de los autores

An AI developer often has several candidate versions of a system and can deploy a mixture of them, sending each request to a randomly chosen version, as in A/B testing. Each stakeholder (e.g., a safety team, a regulator, or a customer with private test data) accepts a mixture exactly when its expected performance (e.g., its rate of harmful replies) meets the stakeholder's own standard, which the developer can learn only by asking whether a proposed mixture is acceptable. We model this as choosing a lottery over alternatives for agents, each of whom accepts exactly the lotteries in an unknown halfspace and answers such binary membership queries. While Choo et al. (ICML 2026) sought a lottery that every agent accepts, none may exist when, say, safety and helpfulness requirements conflict, so we minimize the number of rejecting agents. We show that this problem is APX-hard even when all halfspaces are known and all utilities are or . We then give exact algorithms that run in polynomial time when is constant, and in quasi-polynomial time when, for a constant , some optimal lottery has no accepting agent within of its threshold. When only some agents can be queried, optimizing over a uniform sample of agents gives additive and relative guarantees for the whole population, with a sample size that does not depend on , and a linear program gives a polynomial-time method for any . On the other hand, for , a deterministic algorithm that queries only distinct agents cannot guarantee fewer than extra rejections, and this is achievable; in other words, it can guarantee nothing for the agents it does not ask. Small synthetic experiments indicate that our worst-case bounds are conservative on random instances.

Resultado principalLimitación que admiten los autores

Apareció: viernes, 30 de octubre. arXiv. Preprint, todavía sin revisión por pares.

Comentario de los autores: 31 pages, full version of paper at NeurIPS 2026