pipette
ENEnglish

Quasinormal-mode stability bounds in gravitational EFT: resolvability, predictivity, and positivity

Leonardo Juliano, Enrico Trincherini

Preprint

En palabras de los autores

It has been proposed that consistency limits how slowly black holes can ring down in extensions of General Relativity: effective-field-theory (EFT) corrections may lengthen the decay time of a quasinormal mode by at most about one oscillation period, . We argue that, under standard power counting, this condition yields no new, model-independent constraint on gravitational EFTs. First, its motivation does not extend straightforwardly to black holes: the inverse oscillation frequency is not a universal, detector-independent uncertainty in the damping time of a classical waveform. Our main argument, however, rests on eikonal power counting alone. The decay-time shift grows with the angular momentum of the mode, but so does the weight of higher-derivative operators. When curvature and derivatives are controlled by a single scale , as in every known ultraviolet completion, the EFT around a black hole of radius remains predictive up to , and the shift becomes of order one only there, where an infinite tower of operators contributes at the same order. A resolvable shift within the predictive regime requires either large numerical coefficients or a two-scale power counting, which has no known ultraviolet completion. In both cases the quartic-curvature operators dominate, and the condition coincides parametrically with the positivity bounds that flat-space graviton amplitudes impose under standard assumptions on the ultraviolet completion. Only in scalar--tensor theories could the two-scale window probe beyond positivity, and then at most one family of dimension-ten operators. The axial sector of Einstein--dilaton--Gauss--Bonnet gravity and Einstein--Maxwell theory illustrate these results.

Resultado principalLimitación que admiten los autores

Apareció: jueves, 22 de octubre. arXiv. Preprint, todavía sin revisión por pares.

Comentario de los autores: 19 pages, 3 figures