pipette
ENEnglish

PremiseCheck: Efficient Fact-Checking of Human and AI Peer Reviews

Dingjie Song, Zhiling Yan, Ziqian Zhang, Yuxuan Zhang, Lichao Sun

PreprintCódigo disponible

En palabras de los autores

Peer review is under strain from the growth of submissions, and review comments written by humans or AI can misstate what a paper says. We introduce ReviewFact, a benchmark that labels such factual errors in review comments under one definition across NLP, machine learning, and the natural sciences, and that measures cost and latency alongside accuracy. A frontier LLM checks comments well but must read the whole paper for each check, while cheap decision models, which score whether a statement holds in a text, fall far short on whole comments that mix several implicit assertions. PremiseCheck is a framework that combines the two. An LLM rewrites each comment as explicit premises without reading the paper, and a decision model checks each premise against the paper. When each comment is checked on its own, PremiseCheck reaches accuracy comparable to GPT-5.5 across all three fields at about half its cost, and on NLP reviews at a quarter of its cost and less than half its latency.

Resultado principalEl resumen no menciona limitaciones.

Apareció: viernes, 16 de octubre. arXiv. Preprint, todavía sin revisión por pares.

Comentario de los autores: 29 pages, 19 figures, 23 tables. Code: https://github.com/OpenLAIR/PremiseCheck