Reliability of 3T quantitative human brain MRI is preserved after scanner relocation
In the authors' words
Quantitative magnetic resonance imaging (qMRI) supports both basic neuroscience and clinical research, providing the foundation for longitudinal studies of brain development, aging, and neurological disease. However, its validity rests on a little-studied assumption: that physical relocation of imaging hardware leaves underlying neuroimaging biomarkers intact. When research facilities expand or modernize, an entire scanner undergoes radical disruption--field ramp-down, physical transport, shielding reconstruction, and re-shimming. Whether qMRI metrics remain stable following such invasive procedures without introducing systematic biases is largely unquantified. Here, we systematically evaluated the impact of relocating a 3T clinical scanner over a distance of 30 km on a broad, multimodal suite of neuroimaging markers in healthy volunteers. To disentangle variance components, we benchmarked within- and cross-site stability using percent variation (PV; measurement precision), intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC; absolute reliability), and Spearman rank correlations (R2; spatial and order agreement). We show that scanner relocation introduces no greater variance than baseline within-site assessments. High-resolution brain structural morphometry from different sequences (multi-echo MPRAGE, compressed sensing MPR2RAGE) and quantitative relaxometry (compressed sensing MP2RAGE T1 mapping) demonstrated excellent stability (PV<1%, ICC=0.89-0.99, R2>0.93). Diffusion tensor (mean diffusivity: MD, fractional anisotropy: FA) and mean signal kurtosis (MSK) metrics from multi-shell diffusion MRI maintained low variability across white and deep gray matter (global cross-site ICC>0.90; global PV: MD<1.7%, MSK<1.2%, FA<3.8%; global R2: MSK>0.93; MD>0.90; FA>0.77), confirming relocation robustness for diffusion-derived microstructural markers. Resting-state functional networks displayed high cross-site reproducibility (ICC>0.90), while task-based fMRI activation peaks retained acceptable spatial and magnitude agreement (ICC=0.30-0.60) despite intrinsic physiological variability. In the absence of software or hardware upgrades, physical scanner relocation leaves qMRI biomarkers remarkably intact--providing the empirical foundation required to preserve data integrity across major facility transitions and multi-site longitudinal cohorts. Key points that summarize the paperO_LIHardware transitions do not compromise qMRI data integrity: Physical relocation of a 3T scanner (including field ramp-down, 30 km transport, and re-shimming) introduces no greater variance in quantitative MRI metrics than baseline within-site test-retest assessments. C_LIO_LIMultimodal biomarker robustness: Brain morphometry, T1 relaxometry, diffusion tensor and kurtosis, resting-state functional connectivity display comparable within- and cross-site stability reflected by different metrics (percent variation, intraclass correlation coefficient and Spearman correlation) C_LIO_LIEmpirical backing for longitudinal research: In the absence of hardware or software upgrades, multimodal qMRI biomarkers remain remarkably stable, reassuring researchers that long-term cohort studies and multi-site harmonization can survive major facility relocations. C_LI Graphical Abstract O_FIG O_LINKSMALLFIG WIDTH=200 HEIGHT=175 SRC="FIGDIR/small/26363342v1_ufig1.gif" ALT="Figure 1"> View larger version (57K): org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@1570f5corg.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@b18494org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@773d03org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@46a09b_HPS_FORMAT_FIGEXP M_FIG This study evaluates the impact of physically relocating a 3T MRI scanner on neuroimaging biomarkers. By comparing before and after relocation sessions on healthy volunteers, we conclude that the procedure does not introduce significant variability. Parameters for morphometry, T1 relaxometry, diffusion, and resting-state functional connectivity show high stability. Task-based fMRI showed greater within-site variability, but no increase in variability following relocation, consistent with the inherently higher variability of task-evoked responses.. The results confirm the integrity of qMRI data after infrastructure relocation, ensuring reliability for longitudinal studies. C_FIG
Appeared: Thursday, September 24. medRxiv. Preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.