pipette
ESEspañol

Speculative Imbalance Positions by Non-Physical Traders: Impacts on Electricity System Balancing in Great Britain

Joseph Cary, Thomas Morstyn

PreprintReal-world use

In the authors' words

The electricity system in Great Britain (GB) allows participants to deliberately produce or consume a different volume to their traded position and has incentivised this practice with a single imbalance price since 2015. In particular, non-physical traders (NPTs) often take an open position to imbalance without any intention to produce or consume power. However, new government proposals could restrict this practice due to concerns over supply-demand balancing feasibility and costs. This article presents the first empirical analysis of speculative imbalance positioning (SIP) by NPTs in the GB electricity system through its effects on imbalance volumes, balancing costs, the imbalance price, and associated settlement costs over the period 2021-2024. Our research uses party-level imbalance data in each settlement period to run counterfactual simulations of the electricity balancing mechanism without the aggregate NPT imbalance. Our results indicate that SIP by NPTs reduced the total net balancing volume required by 3.1-3.9 TWh (16-20%), reduced system imbalance standard deviation by 48-65 MWh (13-17%), reduced balancing costs by {\pounds}347-396m (5.9-6.7%), and reduced supplier imbalance costs by {\pounds}193-325m (65-75%) over the analysis period. These results suggest that consumer bills would have been higher without SIP by NPTs, since the extra costs would likely have been passed on to consumers through levies, although the potential for effects in the wholesale (primarily late-stage intraday) markets complicates this picture.

Main resultLimitation the authors admit

In plain words AI summary

Non-physical traders in Great Britain's electricity system often take positions that deliberately create imbalances without producing or consuming power. The authors analyzed data from 2021-2024 to measure how this speculative practice affects balancing volumes, costs, and prices. They found this trading reduced total net balancing volume by 16-20% and balancing costs by 5.9-6.7%, saving £347-396 million. Supplier imbalance costs fell even more sharply, by 65-75% or £193-325 million. The results suggest consumer bills would likely have been higher without this trading, though effects on wholesale markets may complicate this.

Written by Kimi K2.5 using only the abstract above. Jev checked that every sentence is supported by the abstract sentences it cites, and removed any that were not. Point at a sentence to highlight its source.

Appeared: Wednesday, October 21. arXiv. Preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.