Hidden Monogenic Diagnoses in Young-Onset Dialysis After Exclusion of Clinically Apparent Polycystic Kidney Disease
In the authors' words
Background: Genomic reassessment may reveal clinically relevant diagnoses in patients with young-onset kidney failure despite established clinical diagnostic labels. We evaluated this approach after excluding clinically apparent polycystic kidney disease (PKD). Methods: Among 1,139 patients receiving maintenance dialysis at participating Japanese facilities, 355 had initiated dialysis at age [≤]50 years. After excluding 17 patients with clinically apparent PKD, 108 of 338 eligible patients underwent whole-genome sequencing through voluntary, nonrandom enrollment. Analysis included 465 nuclear candidate genes, mitochondrial DNA, and copy-number/structural variants. Clinically concordant diagnoses were adjudicated using integrated clinical and genetic evidence, with a separate pathogenic/likely pathogenic (P/LP)-supported subset. Results: Diagnoses were identified in 10/108 participants (9.3%; 95% confidence interval, 5.1-16.2), comprising seven renal and three systemic/metabolic diagnoses. Nine diagnoses were P/LP-supported (8.3%; 95% confidence interval, 4.4-15.1). The remaining diagnosis was phenotype-based clinical Dent disease associated with a CLCN5 variant of uncertain significance. Diagnoses occurred across diabetic kidney disease, nephrosclerosis, chronic glomerulonephritis, unknown-cause, and other clinical categories. In a post hoc analysis excluding three participants with low target coverage, the integrated and P/LP-supported proportions were 9/105 (8.6%) and 8/105 (7.6%). Six exploratory findings were excluded from both diagnostic numerators. Gitelman syndrome was included as a clinically manifest renal disorder, although its contribution to kidney failure remained uncertain. Conclusions: Integrated genomic assessment can uncover renal and systemic/metabolic diagnoses across conventional labels in young-onset kidney failure after exclusion of clinically apparent PKD. Nonrandom enrollment and variable sequencing coverage limit generalizability and interpretation of negative results.
Appeared: Tuesday, October 20. medRxiv. Preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.