Game structure shapes normative preferences and inter-brain neural synchrony in free-allocation public goods games
In the authors' words
Threshold public goods games (TPGGs) are generally expected to facilitate coordination more effectively than linear public goods games (LPGGs), because an explicit provision point can support non-zero equilibria and transform a social dilemma into a coordination problem. This prediction, however, is based largely on settings in which group members contribute to a single shared pool. Whether it extends to environments in which individuals freely allocate resources across multiple partners remains unknown. Here, using a three-person ring network and functional near-infrared spectroscopy hyperscanning, we examined how free allocation shaped behavioral and neural signatures in the two game structures. Contrary to conventional expectations, the LPGG produced stronger partner-specific reciprocity and greater alignment to history-dependent contribution standards than the TPGG. This behavioral differentiation was accompanied by stronger dyadic inter-brain synchrony in the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex during the LPGG. The two structures also elicited distinct patterns of individual neural activity and dmPFC--rTPJ functional connectivity. These findings suggest that the expected coordination advantage of threshold public goods games may not generalize to settings that allow partner-specific resource allocation, highlighting the importance of allocation flexibility in shaping the relationship between game structure and cooperative behavior.
Appeared: Wednesday, November 18. bioRxiv. Preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.