Non-trivial compositionality in chimpanzees: an experimental demonstration
In the authors' words
Compositional syntax - the ability to combine meaningful units into structured sequences whose overall meaning depends on both the meanings of the parts and their combination - is a hallmark of human language. Recent work suggests that chimpanzees may exhibit similar capacities, raising the possibility that compositionality predates the emergence of language in humans. However, a key challenge has been to exclude simpler explanations in which call combinations are processed as independent utterances rather than integrated structures. Here, we address this issue using a source-manipulation paradigm in playback experiments with captive chimpanzees (n = 6) at the Sigean African Reserve, France. We presented sequences combining alarm and recruitment calls either from a single source (one loudspeaker) or from two spatially distinct sources (two loudspeakers). If sequences are interpreted as independent calls, responses should not differ between conditions. Instead, chimpanzees responded significantly faster when sequences originated from a single source. Bayesian survival analyses confirmed this effect. These results support a non-trivial form of compositionality, whereby the meaning of call combinations depends on their integration into a unified sequence produced by a single individual. Our findings provide experimental evidence that key features of linguistic compositionality may have evolutionary roots in the primate lineage.
In plain words AI summary
Compositional syntax means combining meaningful units into structured sequences where the overall meaning depends on both the parts and how they are combined. Researchers tested six captive chimpanzees in France using a playback experiment with alarm and recruitment calls. The calls came from either one loudspeaker or two separate loudspeakers. The chimpanzees responded significantly faster when the calls came from a single source. This supports that chimpanzees integrate call combinations into unified sequences, suggesting compositionality may have evolutionary roots in primates.
Written by Kimi K2.5 using only the abstract above. Jev checked that every sentence is supported by the abstract sentences it cites, and removed any that were not. Point at a sentence to highlight its source.
Appeared: Monday, October 12. bioRxiv. Preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.