Large and persistent social risks to forest carbon projects
In the authors' words
Despite the popularity of carbon credits as a tool to offset greenhouse gas emissions, there are growing concerns over whether their climate mitigation claims are robust. Most attention has focused on natural risks to forest carbon projects, such as wildfire, while social risks (e.g., those driven by fraud, mismanagement, and land conflicts) remain largely unquantified. Here we analyze 244 forest-based carbon projects to assess the vulnerability of the voluntary carbon market to social risks and find that projects systematically underestimate their risk of failure. Even under optimistic assumptions, projects are roughly twice as likely to fail within 25 years as their self-assessed risk implies over a 100-year horizon. Projecting these trends forward, we show that credits issued to failed projects could exceed the reserves registries hold to mitigate these risks within 1-2 decades. Overall, our results suggest stronger mechanisms and reserves are needed to ensure carbon credits deliver the promised climate benefits.
In plain words AI summary
Carbon credits are popular for offsetting emissions, but their climate claims face growing doubts. The authors analyzed 244 forest carbon projects and found they systematically underestimate their failure risk. Even optimistically, projects are about twice as likely to fail within 25 years as they claim over 100 years. Credits from failed projects could exceed registry reserves within 1-2 decades. Stronger mechanisms and reserves may be needed to ensure credits deliver promised climate benefits.
Written by Kimi K2.5 using only the abstract above. Jev checked that every sentence is supported by the abstract sentences it cites, and removed any that were not. Point at a sentence to highlight its source. 1 sentence was removed for not being supported by the abstract.
Appeared: Wednesday, October 7. bioRxiv. Preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.