pipette
ESEspañol

Beauty Is Human: When People Love AI-Generated Art, They Think a Human Made It

Zihan Chen, Di Zhu, Lei Nico Zheng

PreprintBroad interestEasy to read

In the authors' words

Generative AI now produces images and poems that people cannot reliably distinguish from human-made work, so people often judge for themselves who made a work. We examine how these perceived-authorship judgments relate to aesthetic preference. In a public online AI Art Turing Test, 11,123 people judged whether each of 50 pictures (26 AI-generated) was made by a human and were asked for their favourite. Among the 9,152 respondents who judged their favourite, a picture was 22.1 percentage points more likely to be judged human-made when it was the respondent's favourite, holding respondent and picture fixed. The association was similar for AI-generated and human-made favourites, was positive for all 50 pictures, and appeared under every reported detection strategy. Respondents most negative about AI art chose fewer AI-generated favourites (47% against 60% among the most positive) but more often believed them human-made, partly because others also judged those pictures human. As a result, in every opinion group a third to two fifths of respondents named an AI-generated favourite they believed human-made. A reanalysis of a published experiment on AI-generated poetry, in which 230 people rated each poem before judging its authorship, found the same pattern, although the AI poems were rated higher. When provenance is hidden, liking and perceived human authorship travel together, consistent with aesthetic response serving as evidence of a human maker and with beliefs about the maker shaping enjoyment. The findings qualify research on bias against AI art, which typically uses explicit labels, and inform AI disclosure policy.

Main resultThe abstract does not state a limitation.

In plain words AI summary

People were 22.1 percentage points more likely to think their favorite picture was human-made, whether it actually was or not. This pattern held for all pictures and all ways people tried to detect AI, and also appeared in a separate poetry study. Even people most opposed to AI art often believed their favorite AI-generated picture was human-made. When the source is hidden, liking a work and thinking it is human-made go together, suggesting beliefs about the maker shape enjoyment.

Written by Kimi K2.5 using only the abstract above. Jev checked that every sentence is supported by the abstract sentences it cites, and removed any that were not. Point at a sentence to highlight its source. 1 sentence was removed for not being supported by the abstract.

Appeared: Friday, October 30. arXiv. Preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.

Authors' comment: 22 pages, 4 figures, 12 tables. Working paper