Operational Meaning of the Mandelstam-Tamm Time Scale in a Spin-1/2 Clock
In the authors' words
Georgiev's analysis of a freely precessing spin correctly emphasizes that the Mandelstam-Tamm quantity is not the variance of a time operator. He concludes, however, that its divergence near the extrema of the clock signal is devoid of physical meaning and that does not disclose how well the system measures the passage of time. For the same projective readout, we show that equals the inverse square root of the classical Fisher information in one binary outcome at regular operating points. Its divergence at submaximal-coherence extrema therefore identifies a loss of local sensitivity in the selected readout, not an infinite variance of physical time; a complementary measurement remains informative. This interpretation also separates Georgiev's exactly known tick--tock period from the statistical precision with which a tick can be located. It preserves his warning against a time-operator interpretation while qualifying his stronger conclusion that the Mandelstam--Tamm scale lacks physical content.
Appeared: Tuesday, October 20. arXiv. Preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.
Authors' comment: A Comment on Georgiev, Symmetry (16), 100 (2024)