You All Need to Hear This: Wisdom of Crowds with Deliberating Jurors
In the authors' words
We analyze a formal model of deliberation in which agents have probabilistic access to evidence and selectively disclose it to their peers in order to induce opinion change. We present theoretical and simulation results that tackle the question: does deliberation improve the collective accuracy of the group? Through a jury theorem we chart the conditions that allow wisdom of crowds to emerge after a few steps of deliberation, and, through simulations, we show how this effect is sensitive to the evidence acquisition mechanism and, implicitly, to the diversity in the initial evidence distribution.
Main resultThe abstract does not state a limitation.
Appeared: Wednesday, October 7. arXiv. Preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.
Authors' comment: Full version with proofs of ADT 2026 paper