A general no-go theorem for loss-free optical torque, and its enantiomer-differential escape route
In the authors' words
We show that an isotropic, lossless dipolar particle, locally embedded in a homogeneous, lossless host, cannot experience axial optical torque under any illumination, in any photonic environment, whatever its own chirality--a general identity extending the sphere-in-free-space result to arbitrary chiral and substrate-coupled environments. Shape anisotropy is the essential escape route, and the resulting torque is not generic: closed-form, radiative-reaction-dressed polarizabilities for a chiral dielectric ellipsoid show its loss-free "optical spanner" torque changing by an order of magnitude between enantiomers (\kappa \to -\kappa), a mechanical response impossible for any sphere. Above a high-index or lossy substrate like gold or silicon, standing-wave enhancement, or simply a larger particle at a near-contact gap, brings it beyond optical-torque-wrench thresholds.
Appeared: Friday, September 25. arXiv. Preprint, not yet peer-reviewed.
Authors' comment: 8 pages, 2 figures