{"model":"jev-latest","questions":{"topic":"Which topic best describes what this paper is about?","kind":"What is the main contribution of this paper?","evidence":"What is the main kind of evidence behind the paper's claims?","key":"Which sentence in `sentences` states the paper's main result or contribution most directly?","caveat":"Which sentence in `sentences` admits a limitation or weakness of this study's own results (for example a small sample, a narrow setting, or a result that still needs confirmation)? A sentence describing what was unknown before the study is not a limitation. Answer `none` if no sentence admits a limitation.","appeal":"Who would find this paper interesting?","advance":"How big a step forward does the paper claim to be, judging only from its title and abstract?","level":"How hard is the abstract to understand?","hype":"Does the abstract claim more than the evidence it describes can support, for example sweeping or promotional claims based on limited experiments?","practical":"Does the abstract describe a result that could directly affect people's health, the environment, or technology that people use?"},"scales":{"appeal":["Only specialists in this exact subfield would care about it","Researchers across this field would find it interesting","Scientists from other fields would find it interesting","A curious member of the public would find it fascinating"],"advance":["A small incremental improvement or a minor variation of known work","A solid, useful contribution to its field","A substantial advance that changes how the field approaches a problem","Potentially field-changing: a breakthrough or a first-of-its-kind result"],"level":["A general reader can understand the abstract","Understanding the abstract needs some university-level background in the field","Only specialists can understand the abstract"]},"kinds":[{"id":"method","en":"New method","es":"Método nuevo","d":"The paper introduces a new method, model, algorithm, technique, device or design and shows how well it works."},{"id":"finding","en":"New finding","es":"Hallazgo nuevo","d":"The paper reports a new observation, measurement or experimental result about the natural, living or social world."},{"id":"theory","en":"Theory","es":"Teoría","d":"The paper proves theorems or develops a theoretical or mathematical framework."},{"id":"resource","en":"Dataset or tool","es":"Datos o herramienta","d":"The paper's main contribution is a new dataset, benchmark, software tool, database or catalogue for others to use."},{"id":"review","en":"Review","es":"Revisión","d":"The paper reviews, surveys or synthesizes existing research, including meta-analyses."},{"id":"perspective","en":"Perspective","es":"Opinión","d":"The paper argues a position, proposes an agenda or discusses ideas without presenting new results."}],"evidence":[{"id":"proof","en":"Mathematical proof","es":"Demostración matemática","d":"Mathematical proof or formal derivation."},{"id":"computation","en":"Simulation or modeling","es":"Simulación o modelo","d":"Computer simulations, numerical calculations or theoretical modeling."},{"id":"benchmark","en":"Computational experiments","es":"Experimentos computacionales","d":"Experiments that run software or AI models on datasets or benchmarks."},{"id":"lab","en":"Lab experiments","es":"Experimentos de laboratorio","d":"Physical experiments in a laboratory, including cells, tissues, animals, materials or devices."},{"id":"observation","en":"Real-world data","es":"Datos del mundo real","d":"Analysis of observational or real-world data: telescope observations, field measurements, health records, surveys or cohorts."},{"id":"trial","en":"Clinical trial","es":"Ensayo clínico","d":"A randomized controlled trial or other prospective clinical trial in humans."},{"id":"synthesis","en":"Synthesis of studies","es":"Síntesis de estudios","d":"A synthesis of previously published studies: systematic review, meta-analysis or literature review."},{"id":"none","en":"No new evidence","es":"Sin evidencia nueva","d":"No new evidence: argument, opinion or proposal only."}],"ranking":"rank = appeal + 0.9·advance + 0.4·practical − 2.4·max(0, hype − 0.5) − 0.25·level, papers flagged for bold claims (hype ≥ 0.6) are left out of the edition, then at most 3 papers per field and 2 per topic in the daily edition, with the best paper of every field considered first.","model_version":"jev-1.13.0"}